Comparing AT&T vs. Verizon iPhone coverage

Two weeks with an AT&T iPhone, following 10 days with a Verizon iPhone, and various observations:

1. I was more impressed with Verizon’s coverage than I am with AT&T’s. I dropped my Virgin 4G because their coverage—the same as Sprint’s—was only 4G in the places where I’m reasonably assured of having good wifi. Atlantic City is the key place I’ve needed fast Internet service, and both Verizon and AT&T step up to the plate. But AT&T data has dropped repeatedly in places where Verizon was fine.

2. That said, I prefer having data during a phone call, and that means AT&T is the clear winner here, as Verizon still cuts off data whenever the phone rings. That’s a flaw in the iPhone, which doesn’t yet have the circuitry to support Verizon data and calls simultaneously.

3. For CES, I’m traveling with both an AT&T iPhone and a Verizon Mifi, and I’m already glad to have both. AT&T drops in both the restaurant here and my hotel room at the Quad, Verizon is nicely supporting me.

4. I’m convinced that AT&T icons on the iPhone screen are designed to be confusing. I was initially disappointed that AT&T LTE didn’t come up while I was in Atlantic City, but their 4G service—which I assume is HSPA+ when it’s not LTE—is speedy as hell, although with lower maxima. (Given the monthly data caps, this might be a good thing.)

But what’s really confusing me about AT&T is that the number of bars and the presence of the LTE signal doesn’t seem to mean diddly. I can have moderate signal and LTE, and still twiddle my thumbs waiting for a page to load on the iPhone. Meanwhile, a single bar + LTE can still give me instant gratification. Not sure if the bar meter is displaying a direct dB signal measurement or whatnot, but I don’t care about that—I want a visual indicator of how well my phone is working, and to hell with the tech details. The AT&T displays seem to be skewed instead towards “make the user happy with the nifty icons, regardless of how his performance will be.”

  • Kirk McElhearn:
    If you live in center of York, you can’t sleep late on Sundays. Very loud bells from the York Minster, around the corner from my hotel.

I’ll look around CES for bell-canceling headphones.

  • Philip Michaels:
    Back at home: Awakened at 2 am by daughter having a bad dream. CES: Awakened by drunk who can’t differentiate room numbers. I hate Vegas.

Try asking for room 555. Lowers the odds of a mixup.

  • Jesse Spector:
    It would, of course, be the ultimate barfgasmic fustercluck if they somehow don’t ratify this thing. But everyone knows that.

Barfgasmic fustercluck? Man, we’ve got to get a Secretary to reread the Prologue to you.

Apparently I am not yet Internet-famous. Get on it, .

  • Jeff Carlson:
    1. MacBook Air power brick and long cable. 2. USB cable for camera. 3. Flask. 4. Ibuprofen. 5. Sanitizing gel. 6. Sanity.
  • Rob Pegoraro:
    You probably won’t need to make room in your luggage for item #6 on the way home.
  • Jeff Carlson:
    #6 mysteriously gets shipped back home midweek. Fortunately, it’s there waiting for you. Have fun! May you avoid the show crud.

I left my sanity at EWR when they shut it down before 2009 CES. TSA never found it again.

A four hour nap is apparently how long it takes for my technical memory of this morning’s work to be overwritten with zeroes.

The Quad review

When I started coming to Vegas in the late-80s, the Imperial Palace was “that place owned by the Nazi sympathizer.” After it was bought out by Harrah’s, it became “the cheap hole where you can stay on the Strip.” Now it’s been renamed The Quad and is undergoing a major renovation. I’ve just arrived for a long stay over the International CES, so I’ll be updating this review as I come up with new things worth noting.

Aside: as a Penn grad, I love that when you type “the quad” into Google, the first two hits are “The Quad Las Vegas” and “The Quad UPenn”, after the dormitory on campus that’s been there since the undergrads could almost remember the real Ben Franklin wandering on campus. (Not really.)

If you remember the IP, The Quad makes its biggest impression when you arrive in the porte cochère or walking in off the Strip—both locations announce a very nice modernist decor, similar to the much more expensive Aria down the Strip. That impression goes away quickly; coming in from the airport shuttle dropoff, you pass by the same stores that are more Ocean City in the off-season than upscale mall, and by the time you get to the casino, it’s the same cramped and confusing layout as it used to be, but with far fewer tacky “Oriental” knick-knacks stolen from racist Sean Connery Bond films.

As before, the only real reason to stay here is Strip access for cheap. I’m in the lowest tier of Caesars premium player status, and my stay for 10 days is under $400; aside from the CES days, I’m getting a full comp. That same rated player status got me a quote of $200-300 a night at other Caesars properties on the Strip, and far higher across the street at Caesars Palace, where bog-standard CES rooms can cost $1,000 a night.

That’s exceedingly strange, because Vegas geography makes proximity look far closer than it actually is. The Quad is, in theory, “right on” the monorail system, and I’m one stop away from the convention center. In practice, I know from experience to budget a 30-minute walk to get to the monorail. Caesars Palace is “just across the street”, but that complex is so sprawling, and crossing the Strip during daytime so difficult, that it can easily be a 60-to-90 minute walk to the monorail from any casino on the other side of the Strip.

However, being on the monorail for CES is crucial. Despite a very frequent bus shuttle system, the traffic here is insane during CES, and the lines to board a shuttle at the end of a day can be a 30-45 minute wait even when the buses are arriving continually. Taking a shuttle to and from the convention center can take 90 minutes and up; the main reason I’m staying here is that I’m hoping (first time doing this, so we’ll see if I’m right) that the monorail will be traffic-immune, so commuting to and from the convention floor will minimize but not eliminate travel horror stories.

The hotel room is easily characterized as “Vegas motel”, which is not damning with faint praise because motels here, excluding the Downtown area, are surprisingly decent. Unlike a motel, the king bed has a good mattress, but otherwise the room is spartan; the only amenity I care about is a comfy chair from which to do my writing, and I don’t have one.

Surprising touches: an itty-bitty accessible balcony overlooking the pool. OTOH, AT&T reception here is touch-and-go, but I’ve got great Verizon Mifi signal. And the room has real mugs and glasses, while even the fancy rooms in Atlantic City get styrofoam.

Unpleasant surprises: I’m on the 6th floor, but even so the water pressure is mediocre, and I was ankle-deep in water after a shower. The room would be spacious, but it’s so underfurnished that the arrangement is deliberately inefficient. You could easily put a sitting area in here next to the dining table if you moved the bed.

From what I’m overhearing from the hotel staff, the rates here are still dirt cheap because it’s undergoing renovation through 2014. I assume that afterwards, this is going to be a standard Caesars Strip property with rates to match. That’s rather a shame, as the best thing about Imperial Palace was its availability for budget travel when everything else here was booked. I’d rather not see this place become just another interchangeable property in the mile-long Caesars block of the Strip.

Had a late dinner last night at Hash House a Go Go. The menu advertises the “Sage Fried Chicken Benedict” as featured on Man vs. Food, and I can believe it. Recommended for people who like their dinners served with a shovel; after a very stressful day of missed bus connections, flying, and nibbling on pretzels in lieu of actual meals, it was damned near perfect.

  • Shawn King:
    “Google announced its partners will unveil Google TV products at CES…” What…AGAIN!? Hey Google – no one wanted Google TV the first time.

I look forward to watching Google TV partners on my Q receiver. Along with the three other people who bought one.

  • Peter Cohen:
    Thanks to for putting me on Engadget’s Who to follow on Twitter: Apple edition list, and welcome to new followers!
  • Ian Schray:
    I followed you before you were cool. You’ve changed, man.

We should buy a robe, because then he might let us touch His hem.